Pages

Showing posts with label Book Reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, July 22, 2017

Book Review: Gandhi Before India

The history of mankind, if one skims through, is merely a repetitive record of the violence that one perpetrates upon the other. Each era is punctuated with the leaders who defined the course of such events. The garb of nationalism and other paraphernalia associated with it are merely the tools in the hands of these leaders to gather the masses behind them. It was not until the arrival of Gandhi that morality of neither those tools nor the end that is sought to be achieved mattered much. His methods questioned the very basis upon which power was exercised by one over the other. The history of this man is the history of the mankind and its self-discovery of its moral compass. The invention by Gandhi of his methods did not happen over a single day or over a single incident. It was a gradual process of evolution and a self-discovery, a most important part of which happened in the continent of Africa. Mind that this transformation is from being an abject failure as a lawyer in his homeland to being an undisputed leader of the civil resistance is the story that was carried out of Africa. The man that we know as Gandhi in India was discovered by Gandhi himself only in this sojourn. But this history is a relatively immaterial happening for most of his biographers were blithe loathsome to dedicate time and space to this part of his story. The narrative importance of this part of his life can be better understood when we see that Gandhi himself sees South Africa as the place where he discovered the means to achieve the ultimate end of emancipation for his homeland from the colonial rule. It is a startling journey of a shy man from Kathiawar who cannot even deliver a speech on his own without any assistance to an undisputed leader of Indians. The author himself recognises the narrative importance of this part of the story in the early chapters of this book. The success of this book, more than anything else, depends largely upon the narrative fidelity of the author in taking us through the historical forces of causation that made the man that we saw as 'Mahatma' in India.

Of the Self-Discovery and the Horizons Unraveled

There are not many figures in the world history who has been subject to as much analysis as Gandhi has been. How much ever revered, he was still not without his own eccentricities and blemishes. In fact, he had an unheard of audacity to criticise certain such blemishes on his own in his autobiography. But a third man's account of such how he developed such nuances, which made the man that we know of, is a void that the author seeks to fill in, especially of the time that he spent in Africa. It was an evolutionary process in which his ideals were shaped by his interactions and experiences in one of the most racially prejudiced governments of the world. Of all, his relationship with the native Africans best demonstrates this. He was not free from the prevailing prejudice against the native Africans. This was even overtly visible in the actions of the Gandhi. While he was arguing staunchly for the rights of Indians in Africa and against the racially motivated laws he still abided by the prevailing racial hierarchy. Whites at the top and blacks at the bottom with the Indians floating somewhere in between. Rule be pleaded for equal treatment of Indians, he tried to persuade the authorities by arguing that let not the Indians be treated in the way Africans (Kaffirs) are treated. His petitions to the government to relax some rules specifically targeting the Indians shows a certain degree of apologetic approach that he had in his early days towards the imperial rule. Though justified as an incrementalist approach that he wanted to have in a political struggle, this reminds us again of the Gandhi that we are yet to see. However, what baffles one's mind is when such prejudices, if seen in today's terms, clearly comes in conflict with his ability as a leader. The entry into Transvaal in protest against the racial laws and the demands for equality was only sought for 'educated' and 'cultured' Indians.The struggle that he spearheaded is demonstrative of the very conception of civil liberties that we happen to have today. The recurring use of the qualifiers like 'cultured' and 'educated' to proclaim civil rights just shows that the concept of equality as we see it today was not even thought of then. Even Gandhi himself and his ideas were sequestered to this, confining his activism, at least until then, within these parochial notions of equality. It is baffling by today's standards how he was able to mobilise people cutting across populace regardless of the background. In fact, in the last stages of his struggle for political rights in Africa drew a majority of its support from the lower strata of the Indian populace in Africa, like the indentured labourers. It all, however, ended up as an educative experience for him shaping both him and his ideology with which he landed in India. Rather than dictating outlook towards the world, these encounters along with the extended friendship that he had with people from other races enriched his ideas and provided necessary inputs to forge what he ultimately called as 'Satyagraha'. Either consciously or unconsciously he expanded the horizon of his political views from being a conservative Gujarati baniya to a political leader with worldly views in this two decades worth journey.

Of Gandhi- The Private Man 

All through the book one can see two distinctive personalities of the man. Gandhi- The political leader and Gandhi- The unsuitable family man. Though it has always been my principle not to criticise someone on their actions in personal relationships, I must make a special exception for the likes of Gandhi. I deduce reason thus. I find that all his political proclamations were backed by a strong sense of personal integrity in doing what he says and ask others to do. His political reasoning was entirely built upon his moral construct of self and the discipline in leading a principled life.  It is for this very reason he was able to connect with the masses, unlike any other leader until then. He eased himself into the blurry lines that which political leaders like him unconsciously drew between them and the people that they seek to lead by only preaching what he did. There existed no dividing line between his public and private life when he expected even the members of his family to participate in what he did politically. He was unrelenting in his acts of self-discipline. However, this virtuosity of the man cost him much in his interpersonal relationships. Perhaps he himself realised this, evident from his communications to Kasturba (his wife) where at places he indicates the importance of public work in his life and his inability to dedicate time for the family as much as she would want him to. For a person as important as him it is understandable, however, the real problem arose when he imposed his discipline upon other members around him and it consisted of people outside his family as well. Apart from the relatively difficult relationship that he had with Kasturba the constant struggle that he had with his sons would best demonstrate this. Every single letter that he wrote to his sons reeks of unwanted authoritarian language. He expected them to follow everything he wanted them to till the end. He never seems to have left any legitimate choices for them to make or to discover things for themselves. It would sound paradoxical if one were to see that Gandhi himself was made to be the man that he is because he had the freedom to exercise such choices. If one were to see his history it is the very freedom that he denied his sons which provided him with the means to see the world in his own terms. Had his father been alive, he sure would not have allowed him to travel to London to become a barrister. It is in London that he was exposed to the experiences which came in handy in his ascension to the peak. With his sons, to the contrary, he curtailed any and every means for them explore their abilities in their own terms. His letters are always filled with his exasperation on his unmet expectations, which went even to the extent of asking them to control their carnal instincts. Though a successful leader, he is an abject failure as a father.
His relationship with his wife if seen through the lens of modern standards of women's rights and emancipation Gandhi is an unsurprising failure. All through it is an uneasy civil relationship that they established amongst themselves. The physical attraction played role in their young age (regardless of his later day self-criticism on his inability to be at his father's side on his death due to his carnal desires) but the later day compulsions and Gandhi's exposure to the outside world changed the dynamics of the relationship between them. With his increasing proclivity towards public work his expectations from his wife changed. Being an uneducated and conservative woman, Kasturba at the best could do what he asked her to without any consideration her own sense of self and independent choices. All through, her part in the story of Gandhi is merely a devoted wife standing with her husband's choices, an outcrop of conservative Indian ideals thrust upon a woman. Her sojourn into the gaol in Africa and other participation seems purely out of this devotion, not out of her own intellectual exercise. Gandhi's unilateral decision to practice celibacy is one such decision. Though Kasturba accepted unequivocally it was out of the fact that she did not want to bear any more children. All this is a result his inability to see past his perceptions about the individual that Kasturba was. He grew comfortable in a mechanical role of a 'provider' for his family. One of Gandhi's close friend Millie Polak, who lived in the same house as Gandhis along with her husband, conversation with Gandhi explains this clearly. After being with Gandhi family for a while she told Gandhi that 'the East has made the woman the subject of man, she seems to possess no individual life'. Gandhi characteristically replied that 'The East has given her a position of worship' and went on to quote the story of Satyavan-Savitri. This deification is dangerous reasoning that has been cast upon numerous social institutions of oppression to legitimise it and Gandhi continued to use this reasoning even in the many other beliefs of his own to justify his claims.
Even more unique is the friendship that he cultivated around him. As a person, from what we can see through the history, he might even come across as incorrigible and impracticable due to his eccentricities. But if we want to understand what Gandhi was it is those eccentric reasonings that he professed in his personal life which will give us a peek into it. In fact, his friendship to a great extent grew because of people getting attracted to these eccentricities of his. There was a presence of an overwhelming attraction that transcended such nuances that made the man. Gandhi reciprocally was made to be what he was only with their influence both intellectually and in kind. His friends willingly put themselves in the ways of hardship since they unconditionally believed in what Gandhi did. The strongly knit circle of friends that he fostered in Africa cannot be treated in a conventional sense. They got close to him out of sheer attraction for the principles that he stood for, in that way they were early 'followers' of Gandhian principles.  The very experiment of the Tolstoy farm is an example of how people got influenced by him put themselves to the hardship by willingly abandoning the creature comforts that the modern life offered them.
The most notable of his friends during his time in South Africa was Henry Polak, Hermann Kallenbach and Paranjivan Mehta. Both Polak and Kallenbach attached themselves to Gandhi out of sheer attraction to the principles that he espoused and in fact dedicated their life to those principles. They played a dominant role in Gandhi's political ascension in Africa. Paranjivan Mehta saw Gandhi as the saviour who would emancipate India from its colonial rule. He predicted a greater role that would be played by him in the forthcoming political struggle and wanted him to return to India at the earliest possible. In fact, it was him, who called Gandhi a 'Mahatma' for the first time, not Tagore. He went to great extent to help Gandhi in all mean he could, especially in monetary terms.

Of the Man of Eccentricities

The relationship that Gandhi fostered with people around him had a peculiar flavour to it. Just as it is seen with the relationship that he established with the members of his family he might come across as an eccentric individual who is difficult to deal with in a conventional sense. His beliefs and notions were archaic and are not always grounded in science and logic. Digest this statement of Gandhi, about modern medical facilities, if possible: "modern hospitals perpetuate vice, misery and degradation; had there been no hospitals for cure of venereal diseases, there would be less sexual vice amongst us". I can only imagine the negative impact that a thought which is even remotely influenced by this. He was unnecessarily obsessed with the sexual choices of individuals around him. In many communications that he made with his sons and cousins, he chose to enter into a diatribe on celibacy.

Of Gandhi- The Idea

We often tend to forget that the journey is as important as the destination. Mankind as a whole reached a place where it had to do a moral reevaluation of the progress that it made up until then. It required the directions to lead it somewhere where it can create a just word. It came in the form of Gandhi. Just as Victor Hugo said "You can resist an invading army; you cannot resist an idea whose time has come". Gandhi was an idea whose time had come. He questioned the morality of things that our world took for granted until then. More than the man himself, it is his principles that has endured the passage of time and it is to stay relevant for the future too. We are living in a period where the sense of brotherhood amongst fellow humans has been overtaken by parochial considerations of identity. It is for us to rediscover for our own sake the man that was 'Gandhi'.
A picture is sometimes not a product of an painter's mind. It there present somewhere, to be discovered by the painter. The broad strokes of his brush brings it to life for us to see. Ramchandra Guha has painted this for us to see something as important this. By providing a deep insight into the life the man Ramchandra Guha has done a great service for us all to read. This book is a must read for all who wants to know the man that was Gandhi.

Saturday, May 20, 2017

Book Review: Neither Roses Nor Thorns

If we look at the post-independence history of India one can easily see the tumultuous times that this young nation has gone through to reach the stage where it can call itself a robust democracy. Littered with doubts, the journey was always on the verge of derailment. A few gentlemen of extraordinary grit and calibre saved it, however. With most of those men, as is usual with the history, the importance of their actions and the men themselves have gone unnoticed during their times, except a gifted few. Justice H.R.Khanna is one such man who was celebrated in his times and continues to be a venerated personality of this order. His was the lonely voice that sung the triumph of democracy in testing times. To arrive at a decision with wide ramification to both him personally and to the moral fabric that made the country like India takes the kind of courage that is rarely encountered in the history. What makes the man that he is? The answer comes straight from the horse's mouth in 'Neither Roses Nor Thorns'. The narration starts with his childhood and traces it to his ascension as the judge of the highest court of India. The best part of this journey is that, more than the man himself, it is the importance that he gives for those people who partook the burden of the journey with him. Littered with hear warming anecdotes of such men this book just shows the immense importance that this man gives to others that surrounded him in his life, how much ever small they may be. In spite of being a well-written prose there are significant shortcomings that I felt made the book somewhat of a disappointment. The book does not carry the much-required depth that one would expect from it. The lack of depth makes one to think that this is a half-hearted attempt by the author to write an autobiography. For a towering personality that he is, this book has all the possibilities to set the golden standard in writing, since his life offered immense scope for the grandeur in such a scale. In fact, I was not able to help myself but to draw comparisons with the “Roses in December by M.C.Chagla” (The greatest autobiography ever written in my opinion) against which this book fails in every possible aspect of writing. If my guess is right, this is the mistake of editor who was not able to bring the best out of the author. Another major problem that I encountered in reading this book is that it does not make any chronological sense. At places, it jumbles within the overall timeline without much making sense or purpose confusing the reader. Granted! A non-linear narrative is a style of writing. But it must go organically with the story that the writer intends to convey to the reader, which is missing here.
I was utterly disappointed with the book. However, few stray snippets of information about people and incidents qualifies this book to be a read worth one time. There went the unsung song of one of the greatest composers of the democracy called India.

Thursday, May 19, 2016

Book Review: Idea of Justice by Amartya Sen

Though, like any other person, my mental image of Amartya Sen has always had the element of awe associated with it, not in the least because of the Nobel that he was awarded. In all my attempts at reading his works there arose a consistent feeling of warmth, in part due to the genteel manner with which he address even the scathing criticisms levelled against him and in part due to the overwhelming presence of a uniform train of thought that concerns itself for the betterment of humanity. Both these characteristics of his writings, combined, made his writings a pleasure reading for me. His writings as a philosopher has always had the strand of reasoning that appealed to the rationality within myself, making this book a must read for me. Clearly, as he himself has acknowledged in his several other writings, his education and exposure to the worldly ideas at Shantiniketan, ran by Rabindranath Tagore, has had a great impact in moulding his views. His outlook is global and inclusive at the same time. In a way this book can be seen as a culmination of the broad outlook of ideals that defined his works throughout. For me to peer into one of the greatest mind of contemporary times through his writings is invaluable in its own self. Hence it is with great enthusiasm, which I generally do not associate myself with, that I started reading this book.
Though not a fortuitous happening, Sen, being a contemporary of philosophers like Rawls et al, seems to have enthused by their writings and his encounters with them during his years at Harvard and Oxford clearly has nudged him to explore his own philosophy of what the nature of perfectly just society and its constituent just institutions. Driven by his own conceptions about aspects of a just society he proceeds to expound a possible alternative possibility of a perfectly just society to which a society can work its way to.
Evidently, the Rawlsianism cannot be unlodged as the primary interpretation of justice in the political philosophy in any time soon. Rawlsian theory of justice in effect defined the landscape of debates in 20th Century political philosophy. And it continues to serve as the template upon which any further different forms of understanding of the concepts of Justice is attempted. In this book, invariably, Sen’s exploration of his idea of justice begins with identifying his ideas within the overall construct of Rawls. In fact the first few of the chapters proceeds merely as a criticism of Rawlsian theory of justice. In a condensed form I have tried to produce here only the vital points of criticisms that he mounts up against Rawls
  • The Transcendency of Form: While doubting the very fact that multiple and competing principles of justice while surviving the critical scrutiny can simultaneously claim the impartiality after their emergence from the primordial form of ignorance, as is claimed by Rawls, Sen’s argument takes a unique turn when it questions its practical redundancy. His reasoning is that the identification of a perfectly just social arrangement and institutions cannot be done by the emergence of a solitary reasoning rather than a comparative assessment of possibilities. According to Sen, identification of a transcendentally perfect arrangement in no manner addresses the problem one faces while making choices. The vital aspect of this line of reasoning is that he posits an approach with the help of relative assessment and ranking of available social choices in a decision making process. With this he sows the arguments in support of the setup that expounds in the subsequent chapters.
  • Accounting Differences & Behaviour: Under the Rawlsian perfectly just society, people are expected to behave justly without an exception and are expected to make such choices that are in line with the choice that stands made by them under the veil of ignorance (a primordial state of unknowingness), a Rawlsian innovation. This according to Sen restricts the possibility of choices without accounting for actual behaviour of members of the contract (for Rawlsian just society is established primarily through a social contract). In all fairness one must accept that there can exists multiple social choices that are impartial and can compete with the reasoning of just institution that already stands identified in the contract. The inherent flaw that is present with Rawl's identification of justice is that the members of a social contract may make a choice, even after agreeing upon a just social mechanism, that could withstand critical scrutiny of rationality while at the same time not necessarily in agreement with the choice made already. This possibility comes across as an inherent contradiction when one takes into account the elementary importance that Rawls accords to liberty. This assumption of a spontaneous emergence of a universal reasonable behaviour on the part of all members of a society comes directly in contradiction to still a large question about how the chosen institutions would work in a world in which everyone’s actual behaviour may or may not come fully into line with the identified reasonable behaviour under the Rawlsian contract. This is one offshoot of the problem of transcendency in Rawlsian approach.
  • Parochial Interpretation of Society: While the followers of Rawls has attempted to expand the horizon of his approach to make it more cosmopolitan, it still reeks of the parochial interpretation of society in terms of traditional nation-state theories. This according to Sen restricts the reach of justice in this form for it cannot take into account the effects of a social choice made by a particular set of people over others, i.e. the trans-boundary and external effects of a social choice. Moreover, this also denies the choice makers the information that can make the choice so made sophisticated than what it is.
With these, one might even be tempted to brand this work of Sen as another attempt to overcome the alleged deficiencies in Rawlsian construct and a further extension of it. However, Sen distinguishes himself from those rhetorics with his suggestion of a just social arrangement that is eminently practical, rather than the ‘detached from realities’ arrangements as suggested by Rawls and his followers.
After establishing firmly the deficiencies and inadequate reach of reasoning of Rawls, Sen builds up the case for his conception of justice. There is palpable departure by Sen in his approach to the setup of a just society and the process of decision-making towards such a setup itself. His exposition stands more grounded and practical in its implementation than the transcendental –teeming with multiple infeasible– approach of Rawls. He posits a process wherein all the social choices available are graded according to their relative merits and demerits, rather than identification of a singularly just principle that is expected to govern universally all the choices that are made, without any scope for flexibility. Sen, Rather than confining himself to a mere identification of a just principle, he evinces considerable reasoning for the comparative questions about justice and their social realisations.
Then what according to Sen can be a just social setup? To this end, he draws heavily upon the social choice tradition to construct his version of just society. Though he acknowledges the inherent deficiencies as demonstrated in Condorcet paradox and Arrow’s impossibility theorem, he relies on the broadened informational basis upon which a social choice is made in the social choice theory. Moreover, this conforms to his belief in non-confinement of reasonable and impartial choices that are potentially available for a decision maker while also not restricting the possibility of deviation in behavioural patterns of the people. As far as the process of deciding the rationality of the choices available itself goes, Sen invokes the metaphor of impartial spectator to invoke the concepts of impartiality and reasonableness of any choice. He finds the principles enunciated by Adam Smith in his Theory of Moral Sentiments in this regard to be grossly underrated, which he has vented in an article published earlier as well.[1]
In summation, the form of justice as is conceived by Sen in this work can be simplified in the following terms
  • Plurality of Choices: The central requirement for any approach to justice, according to Sen, lies in its recognition of multiple rational and impartial choices in existence. It is not necessarily axiomatic, as is claimed by Rawls, that only one ideal form of justice and social choice that can lead up to it can exist.[2] He reasons that as long as a choice, that is reasonable, survives the critical scrutiny of rationality is based on a possibly wide informational basis can co-exist with others. While the Rawlsian decision-making process, to the contrary, involves the decision to be made under a ‘veil of ignorance’, wherein decision makers are anonymous and do not know anything about their interests or its effects upon their own. This is an informationally starved decision in comparison to Sen’s process, since here no one can possibly put forward any individualistic nuances that can possibly arise post the decision. Here Sen scores over Rawls without resorting to his elaborate setup of devised uncertainty. Rather than looking for a homogeneous virtue in terms of which all values that we can plausibly defend could be explained,[3] the plurality of reasons can be best judged when the competing principles of justice takes[4] on board the task of accommodating different kinds of reasons and evaluative concerns. The recognition that it is possible to order competition principles of justice, while accommodating their diverse qualitative considerations, and still be able to choose the best alternative as the situation demands is innate for any conception of Justice.
  • Partial Resolution: This is the crucial contribution made by the author overall to the contemporary debates on justice. While stating that it is possible for partial qualitative ranking of available social choices, it is still more possible for a conflict to remain partially resolved with this partial ranking of choices. In his own words
"One implication of this line of reasoning is the recognition that a broad theory of justice that makes room for non-congruent considerations within the body of that broad theory need not thereby make itself incoherent, or unmanageable, or useless. Definite conclusions can emerge despite the plurality. When the competing concerns reflected in that plurality have far-reaching merits, on the relative strength of which we remain partially undecided, then it would make good sense to try to see how far we can go even without resolving completely the problems of relative weights. And sometimes we can go far enough for the theory to be of very considerable use in application, without sacrificing any of the rigorous demands of each competing line of argument."
This, rather than positing a strictly just society, envisages a situation where such steps lead to incremental enhancement of justice in the world. The relative advantage of this line of reasoning is the fact that even a case of non-resolution of conflicting situation does not necessarily make it unworkable. There is always an ever existing flexibility for a change in the choice so made as and when informationally significant aspects comes to the surface.
All being said and done I still feel that there is yet an aspect that Sen has questionably left open. Ironically, this arises from the strongest of arguments put forward by him. While it is plausible for the recognition of partial rankings and any unresolved conflicts in a social choice, it still leaves the question of how to resolve such noughts that arise directly because of this. He does not deal with this sufficiently, while this has the potential to question his theory overall. One possible solution that I can reasonably locate within his line of thinking is that as and when such seemingly irreconcilable situations arise we can broaden our informational perspective to further enhance the quality of available choices. This could reasonably serve as a solution for the limitations of Sen’s position.
Another limitation that I encountered in this book, though this does not necessarily involve his idea of justice, is his treatment of ethics. This I speak with specific reference to the chapter in which he discusses human rights. While treating human rights as certain ethical claims that stand recognized in the form of legislation, he treats the ethical assertions as fountain through which the human rights legislations arises, all this while he does not in any manner exposit the true nature of ethics in itself, leaving it to our own subjective perception. This acquires certain significance when he bases his argument completely over the overarching importance of ethical proclamations in human rights discourse. Although this is inane as a shortcoming, in terms of its impact upon overall argument put forward by the author, it does come across as a pebble in the shoe.
The limitations apart I would treat this as one of the most important contributions to the contemporary debate in the political philosophy post the Rawlsian era. With his innate and characteristic ability to infuse humanitarian reasoning this work stands out amongst the mechanical, elated and unnecessarily esoteric interpretation of justice that is prevalent in the debates. He stands as a maverick in this landscape for his reasoning in this field and this work is his true trophy.


________________________________________
[1] Adam Smith and the Contemporary World, Amartya Sen, Erasmus Journal for Philosophy and Economics, Volume 3, Issue 1, Spring 2010, pp. 50-67.
[2] See in particular Chapter 9- Plurality of Impartial Reasons
[3] Theory of Justice, Amartya Sen, Pg:394
[4] Ibid Pg:395

Wednesday, May 18, 2016

Book Review: Before the Memory Fades

It is not often that you find people who achieve the pinnacle of one’s profession and live to see it. Mr.Nariman, the godfather of Indian bar is one such exception. The very name evokes awe in the minds of many who are a part of the bar and it without any surprises also includes judges who are on the other side of the bar. My first experience of him happened when I was present in the court during his arguments against the proposed NJAC in Supreme Court. I must say there is a quality to his voice and tenor that made me think of Richard Attenborough for a moment. In comparison to the commanding opposition of the Attoney General Mr.Mukul Rohatgi, it was a mellifluous performance that one does not get to witness very often. It is sad that this incandescent voice of the bar is fading due to old age. Naturally as an aspiring member of the bar I picked up this autobiography of his at my first opportunity. With some unexpected eagerness, with which I generally am not associated with for biographies, I started reading the genius of a lawyer’s life. The first few chapters of the book fulfilling my expectations was about his personal life, written in an interesting way laced with sufficient humour to interest the reader. From these pages it is clear that he is from a somewhat well to do background. His professional pedigree too is from the best of stables in the country, chambers of Sir Jamsedji Kanga, of which other stalwarts of the profession like Palkhiwala, Seervai too are a part of. It is actually surprising that even at this age he remembers many interesting incidents at the bar that he fondly reminisces in this book. This part of the book moves without many surprises but with much more gentle humours making it a fast paced interesting albeit not so exciting read altogether.
The real turn in the whole book comes at the stage of his life when he accepts the post of Additional Solicitor General of India and shifts his residence to New Delhi. It happened during the time period when the whole country was at the cusp of radical change of times that will take it into one of most turbulent times that independent India is yet to go through. It was when he was holding this position that the ‘phony’ emergency, as he calls it, was declared in the country, leading to him resigning the post as a form of protest. Considering the then prevailing circumstances when there existed no security even for one’s own life, it was one of the bravest moves that this country has witnessed. As a matter of fact his resignation invited the much needed public attention to the negative effects of the emergency. This particular chapter gives some interesting insight into the mind of the man who mustered the courage to take such a step.
One of the opportunities that Nariman seems to have missed is to appear in the famous Fundamental Rights case (Keshavananda Barati Vs Union of India). His participation in that matter, apart from being a valuable contribution in the case, would have spiced up the reading a little more. The life of a towering personality like him will inevitably touch upon certain watershed moments of Indian judiciary for it is him who played an active role in crafting the outcome of certain number of those pages of history. The subsequent chapters of the book take a definite turn in its tenor and content when he starts to delve into few of those instances. Fraught with controversies even to this day, his decision to defend the Union Carbide in the massive litigation initiated after the Bhopal Gas Tragedy is one such instance. Interestingly he seeks he seeks to justify his stance through this book. Prior to the litigation his reputation for the cause of human rights was internationally celebrated, no less due to his decision not to continue in the post of law officer when the emergency was declared. His reputation in this regard also caused to raise many an eyebrows when he appeared as the lead counsel to defend Union Carbide. In this chapter he explains at length the reality, for much information available to the public are emotionally prejudiced. This chapter in particular helped me no less in understanding several questions that many lawyers are posed in their professional life. Much of the detractors of this decision of Nariman were emotionally opinionated judging him unfairly. But through this chapter he puts up a formidable defence explaining his stance rationally. He has even reproduced two letters (one by renowned Professor Upendra Baxi) that were addressed to him questioning this decision of his. Even prior to reading this book I had several doubts that existed over the role that a lawyer plays in any judicial proceedings. Two extreme forms of reasoning can be had for this question. In one form he is seen as someone who can appear on behalf of anyone that he pleases and in the other he has to judge the cause before entering his appearance. Gandhi, as a lawyer chose the second path. He rejected any cause which he believed is not just. This reasoning of Gandhi is somewhat irrational, for he judges upon the cause of a person even before he is afforded an opportunity before the court. The detractors of this decision of Nariman too sound the like. This reasoning may somewhat put the lawyering as anything for money profession, but the role of a lawyer in judiciary itself calls for it. I personally am not able to see any incongruity in this reasoning and I find it to be rationally robust. As this subject needs separate detailed critical examination I shall refrain from digging further on this. Apart from justification or rather explanation that he offers for his stance in this controversial case, he also offers many judicial solutions to work out of such intricate situations which create difficulties both judicially and emotionally. It does seem to look a little out of place since he himself was and always has been in a veritable position to make such changes. In one page he even offers somewhat of an explanation to this as well, albeit not so convincingly.
The next important chapter is where he narrates his experience as a nominated member of Rajya Sabha (Upper House) of the Parliament. How much ever he seems to have loved it and portrayed it to be a very useful stint as the member, one cannot escape the feeling that his membership was not of much consequence. This is definitely not a surprising when considering the fact that he is nominated member without any party affiliations. Within the political landscape that is fraught with ulterior political motives in every move made, there is little that a sole member can do without the support of major parties on the floor. At its very best his membership did indeed offer the infusion of intellect in the debates held on the floor, sufficing the purpose of his nomination for the membership.
Throughout the passages one can witness the passion that this man holds for this profession. It is hard to miss that in those seemingly autobiographical passages is hidden the man’s eagerness to deliver the message about the ideals for which the profession of advocacy stands for. Hidden is his lament over the disgraceful fall of standards. Nevertheless, more than his reminiscences about the yesteryear members of the bar, who upheld the ideals of the profession, the man himself stands as an exemplar for the wannabes. One thing that I sorely missed in the book is the absence of any interesting information about his maverick of a son Rohinton Nariman. It would have been interesting, personally, to know a little more about the life of Rohinton, whose trailblazing performance as a judge in Supreme Court is raising the standards in the Indian judiciary. All in all this is an extremely interesting read and well serves as an inspiration for aspiring lawyers and lawyers alike.

Abhiram Singh Vs C.D.Commachen: An Inconsistent Doctrinal Application of Secularism

‘Secularism’ in its written form found its part in the Indian Constitution only after an amendment while the presumption of its presence wa...